Saturday, October 25, 2008

Crime and Punishment

As I was busy doing dishes this morning, my oldest came running in, tears flowing, and yelled, "Ellie hit me!" Behind her, cool as a cucumber, my second-born sauntered in. I asked her why she delivered the offending blow and she casually answered, "Because I was naughty." I did my best to hide a chuckle as I escorted her to time out.

Not an hour later, from upstairs, I hear the following:

Lindy: (shrieking like a banshee) "AAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!"
Ian: "Ellie, why is your sister crying?"
Ellie: "Because her bonked her head?"
Lindy: (with intensified volume and pitch) "SHE'S LYING!"
Ian: "How did she bonk her head?"
Ellie: "I hit her."

Needless to say, Ellie has spent significant time in time out today already. Unfortunately, it's getting increasingly difficult to punish this child without betraying the humor of the situation.

8 comments:

Aubri n Scott said...

That is awesome Amy! It is hard when they are so adorable as well! Keep your strength you are doing the right thing!

Autumn said...

Hey...you gotta give her credit for honesty right?? That picture is priceless!

Natelli Johnston said...

hahaha Ellie is so cute! how can you even get mad at her? she is too cute. I have 8 lids Btw.

Teri said...

I love that story! Too funny! It's awesome that you write all of these stories down, they will laugh years to come.

Rochelle said...

Dang! That is the best picture! She's going to love showing that one to her own kids!

Jen Crook said...

That is totally hillarious! I love it!

Tara said...

That picture is classic!

We've had many, many scenarios just like yours. I finally did learn that while the one may be guilty, the other had mastered the "innocent victim" role even when not so innocent.

The Lower Family said...

Got to love 3 year olds!